undoubt
All articles

Brand Strategy

How to Evaluate a Branding Portfolio Before Hiring a Studio

UNDOUBT STUDIO5 min read

Updated

Graphic design book by Michael Bierut beside two pens and a white keyboard

You find a branding studio whose portfolio looks exactly right. The packaging is beautifully photographed, the logos feel considered and the work has the confidence you want for your own business. Before you enquire, look at whether the project shows the kind of decisions your business needs the studio to make.

Knowing how to evaluate a branding portfolio helps you build a shortlist with a reason behind it. You are looking for evidence that a studio can understand an offer, develop a useful identity and carry it into the places customers encounter it. Here is how to read the work and what to ask when the case study leaves a question open.

Cover photograph by Walls.io on Unsplash.

Start with a project that shares your challenge

Choose two or three case studies to examine closely. One might share your industry. Another might solve a similar problem in a different category, such as helping buyers navigate a product range or giving an established business a more coherent identity. Write down the challenge you need help with before browsing, so your shortlist has a consistent basis.

For example, a founder launching six flavours needs to see how a studio handles a product family. A service founder moving into larger engagements may want to examine how the identity supports a clear offer across a website, proposal and presentation. Give more weight to the applications your business will actually use. Ask for a relevant example if the public portfolio concentrates on a different part of the studio’s work.

Look for a relationship between the brief and the design

Read the explanation alongside the images. A useful case study tells you who the brand serves, what it needed to communicate and which choices support that aim. Then see whether you can connect the work to that explanation. When a project describes a range as easy to shop, look for legible variant names, a consistent layout and visible differences between products.

In our REVIVO case study, the brief describes a cleaner, sharper identity for the sports-drink category. The project shows a focused wordmark, consistent typography and different colours across flavours. You can inspect whether those choices connect the range while giving each product its own expression. If you are commissioning a similar system, bring the products shoppers are most likely to confuse into the discussion. Our guide to packaging for product variants explains what to test.

Follow the identity beyond the main image

A full-screen composition gives you one view of a brand. Follow it into the smaller applications too. Look at a product label, a bag, a mobile page or a document with a long heading. Check whether the same principles hold together when the format changes. If the portfolio shows only one application, ask which other formats the studio developed and which ones would be included in your scope.

Our MAMA CHOW’S project shows this through chilli oil labels, boxes, a carrier bag and a social content grid. The case study describes a playful identity built around a confident wordmark and vivid red and black. Compare how those elements carry across the applications. Use your own brand’s likely touchpoints as the next test, especially if your products need more information or a different format.

Unfolded cardboard packaging with daylight branding
Photograph by Annie Spratt on Unsplash.

Establish what the studio actually delivered

Check the credits and scope. Naming, strategy, identity, photography, copywriting, packaging direction and production artwork are different contributions. A studio may have completed some while collaborating with others on the rest. Ask which decisions it owned and which specialists or client teams supplied inputs. This gives you a clearer picture of how the project would run for you.

Also ask whether the work shown is a concept, a commissioned direction or an application that reached production. A mockup can explain an intended design clearly. If your project depends on printed packaging, ask what production files, supplier coordination or proof reviews the studio provides. Use that answer when preparing the project brief.

Separate design evidence from business outcomes

A portfolio can show how a system was designed and where it was applied. When a case study makes a claim about sales, enquiries or customer response, look for the period measured, the source and any other changes happening at the same time. A new product, distribution agreement or advertising campaign can affect the same result. Ask what the evidence supports before using it to predict your own project.

For your shortlist, record the strongest visible evidence instead. You might note that a range uses consistent hierarchy across different sizes, or that the studio has developed both identity and website applications. Write any unanswered questions beside those observations. It makes the next conversation more specific and gives each shortlisted studio a fair chance to explain its contribution.

Turn the shortlist into a decision

Send studios the same business context, priority applications and constraints. Ask how the relevant portfolio work informs their approach to your brief, what they need to learn first and what the final handoff includes. If two studios both look suitable, compare the proposed work using our branding proposal guide.

If the systems in our portfolio reflect what your business needs, explore UNDOUBT STUDIO’s branding packages. Share the project that caught your attention and the challenge you want your own brand to solve.

Source notes. The REVIVO and MAMA CHOW’S examples reference the design scope and applications documented in their linked studio case studies. Both editorial photographs are available under the Unsplash License.

Found this useful?

Views —

Get Updates

Explore practical branding guides, design insights and a closer look at our studio projects. Get updates directly into your inbox.

By signing up, you agree to receive emails from Undoubt Studio. Unsubscribe anytime.